Saturday, May 12, 2012

MC blog: Bass clef blues


Tuesday, May 25, 2004 9:52 AM
Bass clef blues

I really don't know how you pianists do it. Not only can you play multiple notes at a time, you can also play different rhythms and phrases simultaneously with each hand. (I'm a poor, no, a decent, bass clarinetist who creates his musical conversations one note at a time, and it often takes both hands -- and a mouth -- to produce that one note!)

But what really gets me is how you can read two staves at the same time, where the left-hand dots on the staff have a different meaning than the right-hand dots. I just don't get bass clef.

And that's because I've always been a treble clef guy. This may seem confusing because I play a BASS clarinet. However, most bass clarinet music (at least most that I've seen) is written in treble clef, a major ninth above how it sounds (rather than a major second, as with most other B-flat instruments.) My guess is that this is because bass clarinetists are often doublers on soprano clarinet. (Some might say we're soprano clarinetists out slumming!) And soprano clarinet music is written (and sounds) in treble clef.

A few weeks ago I had a wonderful opportunity to play my first classical piece with an orchestra. I had never played with strings before -- unless you count the game of Cat's Cradle. :) Through another musical connection, whose back story I'll fill in later, I was invited to play Franck's Symphony in D Minor with a local community orchestra. I was to have three weekly rehearsals, followed by two performances. So I picked up the sheet music as quickly as possible, in order to practice at home.

Guess what? It was written in bass clef! Now, I can figure bass clef out, a note at a time: "Looks like a treble clef A, so add two and make it a C." However, the tempo was a little too brisk for that, even in the Lento sections. It was even worse than that, because of the major ninth phenomenon: "Looks like a throat A, so add two and make it an upper-register C, oops, no, a lower-register C... Hey, wait for me!"

So, rather than spending the week before my first rehearsal practicing my part, I spent it transposing my part. I used Finale Guitar software (which has much broader application than its name suggests). This way, once I entered the part, I could just push a button to transpose it without error.

"Once I entered the part..." Well! That minor detail took me 15-20 hours, after which I "just" pushed a button. But that time included meticulously double-checking my work. And I was rewarded with a professional-looking copy at the end of it.

It was lots of fun after that. The performances were fun and rewarding, and my part, rest-full though it was, did add a new voice to the music.

My assumption was that, since this was my first exposure to orchestral bass clarinet music, then that genre must normally be written in bass clef. But another woodwind player told me that, although French composers seem to use bass clef, most orchestral BC music is written in treble clef -- that portion of the musical atmosphere where I'm most comfortable breathing.

Do any of you out there have any clef-hanger stories to tell?

No comments:

Post a Comment